Why Talent Alone Never Makes a Story Work.
In 2002, Allen Iverson — A.I. the basketball player, not the potentially world-ending computer technology — went on a now-iconic rant:
“We talkin’ about practice? Practice? Not a game. Not the game that I go out there and die for. We talkin’ about practice!?”
He repeated the word practice another twenty-odd times, turning an otherwise forgettable mid-season press conference into a hilariously uncomfortable cultural moment.
Years later, the writers of Ted Lasso echoed that speech almost beat for beat, this time aimed at Jamie Tartt — the show’s most talented and most stubborn player. It’s a quiet homage, but also a precise diagnosis: both Iverson and Jamie misunderstand what talent actually is.
Not because they lack it — but because they believe it should be enough.
Talent doesn’t make characters interesting. Misunderstanding does.
What the Jamie Tartts and A.I.’s of the world fail to understand is not that practice, teamwork, mentors, or discipline matter. Everyone knows that. The misunderstanding is subtler and far more dangerous:
They believe talent should work on its own.
And that belief — not talent — is what makes them interesting characters.
This applies to athletes, sure. But it applies far more cleanly, and far more usefully, to protagonists and antagonists. A character with extraordinary talent and a false belief about how the world works is a story engine. A character with talent alone is just competent.
At the start of a story, even heroes must be wrong
If Neo understood his own talent at the start of The Matrix, the movie would be short, dull, and over in minutes.
Neo and Agent Smith share the same trait: both can bend the rules of the Matrix — the simulated world they inhabit. But they also share the same misunderstanding: that only agents are allowed to do so.
The difference is not talent.
The difference is thinking.
Neo begins the story believing the rules apply to him. Smith believes they do not. The story doesn’t turn when Neo becomes more talented — it turns when his understanding of reality changes.
(Click here if you want to learn more about what turns Neo the Protagonist into Neo the Hero.)
Talent doesn’t change. Thinking does.
This connects directly to a point we explored in a previous article:
traits don’t change; habits do.
Talent is a trait. It’s largely fixed.
Thinking is a habit. It can be unlearned.
In comedies, it must be unlearned.
The “limiting belief” a protagonist holds — about themselves, the world, or what is possible — is not a personality quirk. It’s the structural reason the story exists at all. Neo, Aladdin, Rocky, Luke Skywalker, Harry Potter — all are extraordinarily gifted from the start. None of them succeed until they abandon a false belief about what that gift means, or how it is allowed to operate.
The misunderstanding is the obstacle.
Talent is just the fuel.
The Talent Checklist (or: why talent is never enough)
Once you give your protagonist exceptional talent, you must surround it with the structures that delay its full expression. Not to weaken the character — but to make the story possible.
Here’s what that usually looks like.
1. A father figure that reinforces the limiting belief
Neo lives in what he believes is the real world — a world that insists, constantly, that he is ordinary. Systems, jobs, authority figures: all of them reinforce the same message.
You are not special.
2. A mentor who does not share that belief
Morpheus believes Neo is the One long before Neo does. Importantly, he doesn’t argue logically — he simply refuses to share Neo’s worldview.
Mentors don’t give heroes talent.
They offer an alternative explanation of reality.
3. An antagonist with comparable talent
Agent Smith knows the truth about the Matrix and exploits it ruthlessly. He is immensely capable — just not as capable as Neo will eventually become.
Antagonists aren’t there to oppose morality.
They’re there to expose the limits of the protagonist’s thinking; they are just as limited in their beliefs themselves.
4. Time to fail in a controlled environment (”We talkin’ about practice?!”)
“Nobody makes their first jump.”
Training sequences exist to prove that talent alone doesn’t work — yet. They dramatize the gap between potential and understanding. They also make the final leap believable.
Yes. Practice matters.
But not for the reason A.I. thinks.
5. A goal that externalizes the misunderstanding
Saving humanity isn’t just a noble aim — it’s a test. Neo cannot succeed while clinging to his old belief system. The goal forces the belief into direct conflict with reality.
(Click here if you want to learn how saving humanity becomes Neo’s Heaven on Earth.)
6. A moment where belief collapses under pressure
Highly talented characters are often the most stubborn. They hit a wall, doubt themselves, and retreat — until something external forces them to act.
In Neo’s case, it isn’t Morpheus’s faith that finally breaks through. It’s Trinity.
Neo doesn’t win because he believes in himself.
He wins because, for a moment, he forgets his belief entirely.
He sacrifices himself for Morpheus. He dies — exactly as the Oracle predicted. And only when Trinity declares her love, insists on his uniqueness, and places herself in danger does Neo finally abandon the limiting belief altogether.
The talent was always there.
The misunderstanding was preventing it from coming through.
Why this matters
Talent doesn’t create story.
Effort doesn’t create story.
Even morality doesn’t create story.
Misunderstanding does.
When talent and misunderstanding pull in opposite directions, narrative tension emerges naturally. When they align, the story collapses — no matter how gifted the character is.
That’s why talent is overrated.
Not because it’s unimportant — but because, on its own, it does nothing at all.
If your characters feel talented but inert, ask yourself one question:
What do they believe about the world that isn’t true?
That belief — not their skill — is what the story is really about.
In the next article, we’ll look at the specific belief that makes success possible — and why every protagonist is wrong about something at the start. Make sure you sign up for the Tale-Spinning newsletter, so you will know as soon as the next article hits the website.